Which mattress is better spring or. Which mattresses are better spring or springless? According to their type of structure, mattresses are of three types

The comfort of your bed plays a very significant role, as it affects the quality of sleep, posture and overall health. That is why it is important to arrange a sleeping place as comfortable as possible and choose a suitable orthopedic mattress, which plays a major role in maintaining the body of a sleeping person. A wide range of mattresses, presented in our time, often makes it difficult for consumers to choose. Let's try to understand the types of these products and the criteria that should be followed when buying.

All mattresses can be divided into 2 main categories:

• Spring mattresses
• Springless mattresses

Usually the choice of a mattress between spring and springless types is the first problem that an unprepared buyer faces. Below we have tried to give a brief but concise description of both types of mattresses, their advantages and disadvantages relative to each other.

Spring mattresses

In such mattresses, a block system of metal springs is installed inside. It is a block containing a different number of twisted springs. There are classic blocks with springs dependent on each other, they are called Bonnel. The parts of the springs are connected in different ways, forming a solid mesh - it can be a rigid metal frame, it can be small springs along the upper coils of large springs. Such products are distinguished by high strength, durability, practicality. But, at the same time, spring mattresses of this design have their drawbacks. Such a surface does not provide an even distribution of body weight, so the sleeping person is like in a hammock. Even such a term was coined - "hammock effect". The springs bend at the same time, but most of all in the place of maximum load, that is, in the center. This is what causes this effect. Therefore, mattresses with a Bonnel block are not recommended for couples whose weight difference is more than 15-20 kg.

In the category of spring mattresses under consideration, it is worth highlighting mattresses with an independent spring block, in which each internal metal part is placed in a separate bag and does not interact with those located nearby. This is a modern and most optimal spring block. Such a sleeping surface distributes the weight properly, providing proper body support and following its contours. In addition, mattresses with an independent spring unit are hygienic, serve for quite a long time, and withstand significant loads. Due to the higher quality, their cost is an order of magnitude higher than Bonnel-type models. In addition, there are several subtypes of spring mattresses with an independent block, the differences between which are in the diameter of the springs and, accordingly, in the spring density per square meter - they are called Multipocket and Micropocket.

Spring mattresses can be of poor quality and pose a health risk. In particular, we are talking about models that have a thin layer of filler on top of the springs. When the material wears out, metal parts often wipe the layer and can create significant discomfort for a sleeping person. There is only one advice - do not buy the cheapest mattresses, then the risk of this is reduced to zero.

Springless mattresses

A large subtype of mattresses, united by a common condition - the absence of any springs in the design. Filled with a special material or materials, there are monolithic or layered. As a rule, natural and synthetic latex, coke coir fibers, polyurethane foam are used in their manufacture. The filling can be combined from several types of filler in the form of a "sandwich". Inexpensive versions of springless mattresses based on a monolithic PPU block - polyurethane foam are very popular.

The disadvantages of springless mattress models are the relatively high cost for mattresses based on natural fillers (it is higher than that of similar spring mattresses due to the greater consumption of material) and the limited life of springless foam mattresses. With all this, mattresses made of coconut fiber, latex or polyurethane foam can have a therapeutic and orthopedic effect. A properly selected product often serves as a means of preventing the development of scoliosis and other orthopedic diseases of the spine.

Characteristics of each type of springless mattresses:

1. latex(natural). They are not affected by dust mites, therefore they are safe for health. However, the material is afraid of moisture and has a fairly large weight. Soft and comfortable products, the cost is high.
2. coconut. Mattresses with such a filler have the necessary rigidity, therefore they are considered the best of the orthopedic ones. They have high air permeability. High price.
3. Combined. With natural materials or partial use of artificial materials. The optimal type of good orthopedic products at quite reasonable prices.
4. Synthetic. We are talking about mattresses with polyurethane foam, orthopen, holofiber and other artificial fillers. They are distinguished by elasticity, affordable price, hypoallergenic qualities and, like coconut ones, they pass air. Of the minuses - the presence of smell and a short service life.

Criterias of choice

The most important difference between a mattress with springs and a mattress without springs lies in the "spring" effect, the characteristics of elasticity, which are inherent in the first option and not inherent in the second. Often this is a very subjective feeling, and you just need to compare both types of mattresses live.

Both spring and springless mattresses are in great demand among our customers. Some choose models with an independent type of metal spring block, others prefer more modern options without springs.

The best option for children aged 0 to 12 years will be orthopedic springless mattresses on coconut coir or natural latex. It is desirable for teenagers to purchase medium-hard sleeping surfaces - spring with an independent block or monolithic latex or polyurethane foam. Adults can choose mattresses depending on their preferences regarding the elasticity of the product. However, if you have problems with your back and spine, the choice of such an element of the bed must be taken very seriously!

• Mattresses made of latex and polyurethane foam deteriorate under the influence of high temperatures and direct sunlight. Do not take them out under the scorching sun and place them next to heating appliances.
• Products with synthetic and natural fillers need ventilation.
• A high-quality mattress should be packed in a jacquard or cotton cover - safe and practical materials that do not accumulate static electricity and have excellent performance.
• Spring sleeping surfaces must not be exposed to moisture to avoid rust formation on metal parts.
• Extend the life of the product will help the use of high-quality mattress topper.

Before buying a mattress, it is advisable to consult with an orthopedist, especially if the products are purchased for children or people with problems with the musculoskeletal system. When choosing a sleeping surface, you should carefully read the characteristics and composition of the product. Good choice!

What will provide the sweetest dream?

Spring mattresses are still more popular than springless models. But the question of which spring mattress is better to choose, which firm to give preference to, often remains open. We offer you rating of the best manufacturers of spring mattresses We hope this will make your search easier.

When choosing a good spring orthopedic mattress, buyers prefer models with an independent spring block. "Price Expert" listened to their opinion, in the rating, as examples, the most popular models of each manufacturer with an independent spring block are presented.

Criteria for choosing a good spring mattress

Spring block. Independent wins - the mattress will sag only in the place where you are lying at the moment.

Rigidity. The criterion depends on your preferences and needs. In any case, you need to try out the mattress before you buy it. The myth that you need to sleep on a hard mattress is just a myth.

materials. Give preference to natural hypoallergenic materials, because you spend almost half of the day on the mattress.

Rating of the best spring mattresses according to "Price Expert"

Let's take a closer look at our winners:

Askona
№1 mattress manufacturer in Russia

Photo: u.askona.ru

In the photo - a popular mattress of medium hardness with an independent spring block Askona Balance Forma.

Price on the manufacturer's website- 7210 rubles.

The company has been operating in the Russian and Western European markets for over 20 years. "Ascona" received the people's Russian award "Mark #1" according to the results of the national Russian voting in 2011 and 2013 in the category "Mattresses for healthy sleep".

The range of orthopedic mattresses exceeds 800 models of various fillings and price categories. Ascona owns a special collection of Mediflex mattresses recommended for the complex treatment and prevention of diseases of the spine and musculoskeletal system.

Advantages of Ascona spring mattresses:

• a huge variety of models with dependent and independent spring block;
• a large price range, for a small price you can pick up an excellent mattress;
• anti-allergic mattresses;
• warranty - from 18 months to 5 years.

disadvantages: not detected.

From reviews of Ascona spring mattresses:

“The best spring mattress we've ever had - doesn't creak, doesn't sag, no dents from lying or sitting, looks like new. For 3 years, they have never regretted that they bought it.

“We have had this mattress for two months already, the period is not so long to talk about all its advantages and disadvantages, but so far I have not noticed any disadvantages, only advantages. We wake up refreshed every morning!”

Vegas
best Belarusian spring mattresses
with European quality certificates

Photo: xn-----6kcarfgwrqroabgmkiqhs5r.xn--p1ai

The photo shows a popular Vegas 20 medium firm mattress with a block of independent springs.

Price on the manufacturer's website- 19080 rub.

The Belarusian company "Vegas" has confirmed the quality of its products with certificates euroLATEX(European quality latex), Oeko-Tex(health safety and hygiene of textiles, spring blocks and orthopedic mattress fillers), ISO(compliance with standards regarding the care of nature in the production process, rational use of energy).

Vegas uses raw materials and components from well-known European suppliers (Germany, Belgium, the Netherlands, Lithuania).

Advantages:

• a variety of sizes, non-standard mattresses, the length / width of which does not exceed 200 cm, are made at no extra charge;
• anti-allergic mattresses;
• high quality and excellent materials;
• Mattresses are guaranteed for 3 years.

disadvantages:

Vegas:

“The mattress normally bends under my forms, but the springs themselves are not felt in any way. I am glad that I did not succumb to the stereotypes that a hard mattress is good for my back, but chose one that is really comfortable for me.

“Now it is very difficult to buy a truly high-quality thing, even for a lot of money. But the company Vegas did not deceive my trust, for which many thanks to her.

Ormatek - innovative technologies and constant progress

Photo: ormatek.com

The photo shows a popular spring mattress of medium hardness based on the block of independent springs Ormatek Optima Mix EVS500.

Price on the manufacturer's website I - 11500 rubles.

The Ormatek company has been operating in Russia since 2001 and occupies 20% of the mattress market in the country. A wide range of products and various characteristics of manufactured mattresses allowed Ormatek to take a strong position in Russia and abroad.

The SmartSpring spring unit has 15 zones of stiffness and perfectly follows the contours of the body. The company "Ormatek" owns the manufacture of a record-breaking mattress, listed in the "Book of Records of Russia" - 114 sq.m.

Advantages:

• a wide range of spring mattresses and a huge variety of fillers;
• guarantee for mattresses - from 2 to 7 years depending on the collection;
• anti-allergic mattresses;
• high quality and comfortable mattresses.

disadvantages:

• price.

From reviews of Ormatek spring mattresses:

“Sleeping at first seemed a bit harsh (5 days), but then the body adapted. Sleeping is a pleasure, you wake up with a rested back, vigorous.

“The best spring mattress - incredibly comfortable, does not collapse, does not wrinkle or lose shape, is well made. There are no foreign smells from it. After a regular mattress, the difference is unreal.”

Perrino spring mattresses - the best price-quality ratio

Photo: perrino.ru

The photo shows the popular premium model Perrino Origant with an independent spring block.

The price from the manufacturer's website is 13590 rubles.

The Russian company Perrino started its work in 2006. Uses high quality European components (Germany, Italy, Belgium). The production is located in Kaliningrad - a free economic zone, so the prices for Perrino mattresses are lower compared to other Russian companies.

All mattresses of the company meet the requirements of GOST.

Advantages:

• own high quality European equipment;
• affordable prices;
• high quality, convenience and natural materials;
• Mattress warranty - 2 years.

disadvantages:

From reviews of spring mattressesPerrino:

“Unlike other companies, they do not require additional payment for lightning. You can always see if they slipped you foam rubber instead of latex. And the price is less than 15 thousand compared to the same mattresses from other manufacturers.

“A slight smell, like from any new thing, was present, but not for long. The mattress is quite comfortable. For now, I'm completely satisfied."

Atmosphere spring mattresses - a combination of machine and hand assembly

Photo: irecommend.ru.q5.r-99.com

In the photo - the popular Atmosphere Planear mattress of medium hardness with an independent block of springs.

Price on the official website of the manufacturer- 17700 rubles.

The Atmosphere factory has been operating since 1992. In the manufacture of mattresses, "green" European technologies are used, which involve only the most environmentally friendly natural materials: horsehair, latex, sisal, cotton and others.

The main feature of Atmosphere mattresses is the production technology, which is an unusual combination of advanced scientific developments and invaluable hand-made experience.

Advantages:

• high quality and natural materials;
• removable cover that is easy to wash;
• mattresses are anti-allergic, this effect is also achieved by the content of bamboo fibers;
• prevention of diseases of the spine;
• made specifically for the weight of the buyer;
• warranty - from 3 to 10 years

disadvantages:

• price.

From reviews of spring mattressesatmosphere:

“We decided to buy a spring mattress from this particular company, because in terms of characteristics it is not inferior to expensive mattresses from advertised companies. For that price, we'd buy a lot worse."

“Atmosphere mattresses are made with the utmost care because they are made by hand rather than by machine. It became very easy to wake up in the morning, the spring mattress is the best!”.

Velam is a manufacturer of the best inexpensive spring mattresses

Photo: www.mirdoma.com.ua

In the photo - a popular model of medium hardness Velam "Seventh Heaven" with an independent block of springs.

Price on the manufacturer's website- 8500 rub.

The Ukrainian company Velam has been operating since 1991 in the mattress market. Repeatedly became the winner of Ukrainian and international competitions (since 2010 - "Industry Leader" in Ukraine, "Best Enterprise of Ukraine" in 2010, "Recognition of the Year" - 2012, etc.), has a number of quality certificates, including ISO , EMRC (Belgium) - for high quality products.

The collection of Velam mattresses consists of four series - Baby, Standard, Lux, Premium. Due to reasonable prices and excellent quality, the company is becoming increasingly popular not only in Ukraine, but also abroad.

Advantages:

• high quality, confirmed by numerous awards, excellent materials, convenience;
• a wide range of spring mattresses;
• great prices;
• anti-allergic mattresses;
• mattress guarantee - 18 months.

disadvantages:

• not a very well-known manufacturer in Russia.

From reviews of Velam spring mattresses:

“Very happy with my Velam mattress. We have been using it for more than 6 years, and although we travel quite a lot at home and abroad, we still haven’t come across a better spring mattress.”

“I bought a spring mattress “Strong” for myself, and “Sapphire” for a child. We've been using it for two years now. Finally, sleep is normal, the back is resting. The quality is the best and the price is reasonable."

Which spring mattress is better to buy?

The mattress should always be chosen exclusively for yourself and for yourself. Therefore, even having decided on the brand or model of the mattress, try it in the salon so as not to be disappointed at home. The firmness and filling of the mattress are selected individually.

"Price Expert" wishes you great shopping and peaceful dreams!

Anatomical mattresses can be divided into two types: spring and springless. Both those and others take into account the anatomical structure of the human body, exclude unnatural sagging of the spine in the supine position. When using an anatomical model, the body exerts pressure on the product in such a way that disc displacement does not occur and, as a result, a person with spinal pathologies does not experience pain.

Note that under models containing springs, we will understand only modern product designs, with additional filler material. This article does not talk about spring structures of the old type.

Compare mattresses

Which anatomical mattress is better: spring or springless? As a rule, most buyers ask this question, referring to anatomical products. Anatomical models designed to help in the treatment of spinal pathologies are bought only on prescription and only in specialized stores. More often they can be found in medical institutions. If a comfortable bed that adapts to the curves of the body is necessary for home use, this is precisely the anatomical option.

Spring anatomical products are divided into two types:

• with a dependent block of springs;
• with independent spring block.

The main difference is that in the first version all the springs are interconnected, i.e. are dependent, and the deflection of one spring causes the movement of the other. Among the mattresses you can find products with a dependent Bonnel spring block. This block of springs is more budgetary, but popular. Although, of course, less durable.

In modern models, the springs are covered on top with high-quality sealing material, which gives the product the necessary rigidity and provides all the conditions for a comfortable sleep. Thanks to a special connection technology, the springs do not creak.

Mattresses with independent springs

A modern mattress with an independent block takes into account the anatomical structure of the body and ensures its correct position during rest. This effect is achieved due to the fact that the springs in the block are placed independently of each other, there is no oscillation. This means that the movements of one of the sleepers will not disturb the sleep of the other. Products have a great anatomical effect and are well suited for people with diseases of the spine.

The catalog of the Askona brand is represented by a large assortment of spring mattresses on an independent block with high anatomy. The patented hourglass-shaped springs have unique properties, are durable and will give you a healthy restful sleep.

Springless mattresses

Springless models are made on the basis of monolithic or stacked blocks with various fillers. Such products evenly distribute the weight of the body, providing it with good support. The main advantage of these models is the absence of metal elements that have an electrostatic or magnetic effect on the body.

The Askona catalog contains a large selection of springless mattresses. In our models, only the best, environmentally friendly, safe for humans fillers, artificial or natural, are used.

Who is suitable spring, and who - springless mattress

The choice of a mattress should begin, first of all, with the answer to the question: for what purpose is it bought?

Choosing a spring-based mattress with an independent block is better for couples with a large difference in weight: there will be no “hammock effect”. If you like to sleep hard like on the floor, you can opt for a springless product. Models with dependent springs are usually purchased at the dacha: they are cheaper than models with independent springs.

conclusions

The choice of a spring or springless model depends on many factors. Before buying, try to lie down on the model you like in different poses. If you are comfortable, you can safely buy this mattress.

The Askona catalog contains a wide range of springless and spring models of various degrees of rigidity and price category. All mattresses are made of breathable and wear-resistant materials.

A well-slept person is positive, looks great, and is ready to solve the most complex production issues. Comfortable, healthy sleep depends on the right mattress, first of all - the degree of its rigidity. The latter depends on the type of filler used, the presence or absence of springs.

To create conditions for a comfortable sleep, it is recommended to purchase orthopedic mattresses. Manufacturers offer them in two types:

• spring,
• springless.

The rigidity of the first is provided by specially selected springs, the second - by a filler, which can be natural or artificial. The materials used are of varying rigidity, demanding and easy to operate. The service life of the products also varies.

Which mattress is better - see the video:

Spring mattresses: their types and features

Spring mattresses remain one of the most popular today. Favorable price-quality ratio, high orthopedic characteristics speak in favor of this class of sleep products.

Manufacturers offer products with spring blocks of two types:

• dependent,
• independent.

At the heart of the first are Bonnel spring blocks, in which steel springs are connected to each other by contact. This technology simplifies production, reduces the cost (and, accordingly, the price) of products. The low cost of sleep products with dependent spring blocks can be considered their only advantage. However, for many buyers, it is very significant.

Spring blocks with independent springs have recently begun to gain popularity. The special "pocket" design allows no contact with metal parts. When using products of this type, there is no unpleasant clanging, which contributes to a calm, healthy sleep. The price is higher, but it is customary to pay for comfort.

The positive characteristics of spring structures depend on the type of blocks used. Dependent are distinguished by average orthopedic properties, moderate rigidity. After layers of sufficiently thick felt were used in them, the springs are practically not felt.

• mattresses with Bonnel blocks have a long service life;
• able to withstand significant (up to 180 kg) loads;
• independent blocks are distinguished by a higher orthopedic effect;
• the ability to install a different number of springs;
• lack of a metal creak;
• low (compared to other types of orthopedic mattresses) price.

• the appearance of rust on the surface of the springs during operation in conditions of high humidity;
• dependent springs emit an unpleasant metallic creak and form a “wave” effect, that is, when one spring is pressed, the neighboring ones start to move (This feature creates uncomfortable sleeping conditions for a person lying nearby, while independent spring blocks do not have such an unpleasant feature).

You may be interested in learning about all the advantages and disadvantages of each of the options for spring mattresses, and decide which one to choose.

Springless mattresses: varieties, features

Springless orthopedic mattresses are considered more comfortable. Various fillers allow you to create sleeping surfaces with any degree of rigidity:

• soft,
• moderate
• tough.

Springless mattresses are distinguished by the structure of the filler:

• monolithic,
• typesetting.

Another type of classification is by type of filler:

• natural,
• artificial,
• combined.

• the main advantage of springless mattresses is the ability to create sleeping surfaces with different elasticity;
• as an additional pleasant bonus, one can name the absence of metal parts that will rust over time;
• materials are able to provide optimal support for the spine.

• the disadvantages of springless mattresses depend on the material of the filler;
• inexpensive ones are favorable in price, but have a short service life;
• Not everyone can afford mattresses with expensive fillers, but they are distinguished by a long service life while maintaining all quality characteristics.
• Popular fillers

The most popular fillers for springless mattresses are:

• coconut fiber,
• natural latex,
• polyurethane foam (PPU),
• memorix.

Coconut

Coconut fiber (coir) is used to create sleeping surfaces with a high degree of rigidity. It is recommended for children's mattresses (including for newborns). Rigid surfaces are useful for people with spinal diseases.

• natural material does not cause allergic reactions;
• ventilated;
• has hygroscopic properties.

• instability to kinks (mattresses made of coconut cannot be twisted).

Latex

Latex is a material with a foamy structure obtained from natural raw materials.

• differs in moderate elasticity;
• able to follow the contours of the body, providing the sleeper with the correct horizontal position;
• does not cause skin irritation;
• does not absorb moisture;
• thanks to the existing pores, it is perfectly ventilated;
• it does not accumulate dust, which prevents the vital activity of dust mites.

• natural latex has a high price, but it is fully justified by its positive characteristics.

polyurethane foam

Polyurethane foam (PPU) is a man-made material, also known as artificial latex.

• has high orthopedic characteristics, well supports the back during sleep in the correct position, follows the contours of the body;
• hypoallergenic;
• passes air and moisture;
• The low price of the material has made it one of the most sought-after fillers for mattresses.

Memorix

Memorix or Memory Foam is an artificial material with a memory effect.

• repeats the contours of the body and retains them for some time;
• has high orthopedic characteristics;
• does not cause allergies;
• well ventilated;
• does not absorb moisture, which prevents putrefaction and mold formation.

• differs in the high price, but creates the most comfortable conditions for a dream.

Having studied the characteristics of both types of orthopedic mattresses, you can determine which one will be ideal - spring or springless. The main criteria by which this can be determined:

• convenience,
• orthopedic indicators,
• life time,
• price.

Convenience

Comfort is an important component of healthy sleep. How comfortable a person feels in bed depends on -

• will he sleep
• whether he will feel cheerful in the morning;
• whether there will be aches in the joints and muscles.

body position

The correct position of the body is provided by all orthopedic mattresses. The main thing is to choose models that correspond to the weight of a sleeping person.

The choice of orthopedic mattress depends on the weight of the person. The larger it is, the harder the sleeping surface should be.

Life time

Price

Cost is one of the most important selection criteria. Many buyers prefer to find a compromise of good quality and affordable price.

Independent selection tips are presented in the video:

In order to purchase a high-quality orthopedic mattress and not regret the wasted money, it is recommended to clearly understand what requirements you place on a sleeping place.

Fans of hard surfaces should pay attention to mattresses with coconut or combined structures such as "latex-coconut". You can choose a spring mattress with a large number of springs per bed.

For fans of moderate firmness, a springless mattress with latex or memorix is ​​suitable. From budget models - a product filled with polyurethane foam. Spring mattresses with dependent and independent blocks also have a medium degree of rigidity.

If an orthopedic mattress is purchased due to problems with the musculoskeletal system, it is recommended to undergo a medical examination and consult a doctor.